Yes, if you pick and choose incidents you might be able to make a reel for any team. There’s always some drunken idiot in the stands. There’s always some good people in the stands (not all Eagles fans). And yes, there are other places that are awful and even worse than Philly. Did you see what Vancouver did when they won the cup? And let’s not even talk about Soccer in Europe or elsewhere.
Yes, that kind of confirmation bias is a thing that exists, but in this case no. I’m not even trash talking here. And it has nothing to do with the fact that I personally hate Philly. It is a fact that Philly fans are worse than fans in other US cities. Fan culture in different cities and for different teams is actually different, and the Eagles and Phillies almost definitely have the worst behaved fanbases of all pro sports team in the US.
Let’s compare by looking at St. Louis. Fans in St. Louis are irritatingly nice. Ever go to a Cardinals game? They fucking cheer for their team when they lose. They could stink up the joint (though they rarely do) and the fans will politely clap anyway. Wearing the visiting team’s jersey? They’ll fucking murder you with politeness. When they win, they celebrate in a classy way. No fires, no violence, it’s all above board.
When Philly won the World Series they rioted.
What other city has done this? Not even the Cubs who won for the first time in forever. Nobody. Only Philly.
I’ve been to more games at Shea Stadium, Citi Field, Gillette Stadium, Fenway, and MSG than I can remember. Even going to the World Series, the visiting Royals fans caused no trouble. We sat next to some, and they were totally behaving properly. Kansas City.
The only time I have seen visiting fans behave poorly was the last game the Phillies every played at Shea stadium. The Philly fans had won the previous games in the series, and it was a double header. They brought actual brooms and waved them about while chanting “sweep sweep sweep”. This wasn’t just one group, it was a whole bunch. No other visiting team had exhibited this kind of behavior. Not when Boston came, not when The Yanks came on the subway, not anyone.
It’s just Philly The fans really are just worse.
Ask yourself. Would you feel safe wearing a Lakers jersey to the Boston Garden? Would you feel safe wearing a Yankees at at a Mets game? Probably.
How about a Giants jersey to Gillette stadium? I’ve done that. I’ve worn a Mets hat to Fenway during the All-Star game and regular season games. No problems.
Now, would you feel safe wearing an Eli Manning Jersey to Lincoln Financial? If so, I dare you to fucking do it. I’ve got one you can borrow. If not, why not?
This reputation didn’t come from nowhere. If you want to get rid of it, then start behaving nicely. You have a chance to prove yourself in a couple weeks. Let’s see what happens.