The Lion King 2019
★★★
Rewatched Sep 11, 2020
I watched The Lion King (2019) last November, and wrote at the time:
“Watched on a plane, so probably a bit more emotional than usual, but this move really got to me. I cried like three times.”
The “watched on a plane” factor was strong in that viewing. It doesn’t hold up quite so well on a second viewing at home.
The main reason is the music. The movie is carrying so much baggage that it only just holds it all together.
Here’s my (rambling) thesis:
The original Lion King was straining under the weight of FOUR different musical styles and composers:
- Tim Rice on lyrics doing musical theatre
- Elton John with music bringing pop sensibilities
- Hans Zimmer doing the orchestral movie scoring (wins Oscar)
- Lebo M providing the traditional African sounds and choir arrangements
The African sounds worked because it was set in Africa, the orchestral score worked because it’s a movie, the musical theatre stuff worked, because at the time Disney animations were pretty much animated Broadway musicals.
It’s a mashup of styles that nailed a singular tone, worked great for the movie, and led to hit songs and a hit album.
The Lion King Musical somehow distilled all these elements, and the due to it being an actual musical, could lean into the musical theatre style and gain huge benefits.
But Lion King 2019 has four new layers of baggage on top:
-
The movie couldn’t leave out the classic songs… so I ended up comparing the actors’ performances to the originals. Chiwetel Ejiofor has a great acting voice, but can’t do Be Prepared like Jeremy Irons. John Oliver barely holds it together for the four lines he has to sing in Just Can’t Wait To Be King.
-
Everyone is used to singing animated characters. It’s what animated characters do. But very lifelike CGI animals… don’t sing. And they don’t do broadways show-style choreography either.
-
Why not bring in Pharrell Williams as music producer? Well, that’s another musical influence to go with the four already mentioned, and the balanced mix is now overloaded.
-
Beyonce is a fantastic performer, but her vocal work doesn’t fit with the pop-duet-musical-theatre number in Do You Feel The Love Tonight. She’s doing soul singing vocal acrobatics, overwhelming the original melody and Donald Glover, not the clear musical theatre vocals the song was written for and needs.
All this is why I think the Lion King Original Broadway Cast Recording is still the best version of The Lion King. It distills all of the strengths of the original movie and its soundtrack into a perfect form: an actual Broadway show.
Lion King 2019 exposes all the aspects of the original movie’s soundtrack that should never have worked! But it somehow did! But now it very much doesn’t!
It’s a modern CGI movie with songs and performances…
that reference songs and performances of a previous animated movie…
that referenced the musical styles of broadway shows…
which in turn are referencing big band music hall dance numbers from the 1930’s.
Too many layers!
Compare and contrast to The Lego Movie 2, which has kickass musical numbers that reference popular music in 2019. The breakdown is the middle of the song is a massive beat drop… you know, like actual music these days. Not like some of the Lion King numbers, which are using the musical language missing from popular music since 1950.
Still, the movie looks very pretty.