Here is a list of all the groups in the largest coalition against the convention.
http://www.nyagainstcorruption.com/who-is-voting-no/
The vast majority of them fall into the following categories:
-
Labor groups. The NY State constitution guarantees rights to collective bargaining and pensions for state workers, as we can see in ballot proposal 2. While I agree with these groups, they are against the convention as a whole because they care about this single issue, and the status quo is currently in their favor. Therefore, they support a no vote even though that results in maintaining the status quo in all areas, not just their one area of interest.
-
Environmental groups. Same as the labor groups. I agree with their cause. The state constitution currently protects a lot of land from development, as seen in ballot proposal 3. They support a no vote because they have a single issue, and the status quo is in favor of that single issue.
-
The rest of the groups range wildly. You got the rifle and pistol association (which is not the NRA, but agrees with the NRA). There are local Democractic parties. You have Make the Road NY, which is an amazing organization. You also have the Republican State Committee and the state Conservative Party, which are the worst and the somehow even more worst.
On the one hand, if this is something that everyone can agree on, maybe the no vote is correct. If we really have something that the Conservative party and the LGBT network agree on, then maybe that something is the way to go.
On the other hand a convention could solve the very problems that might plague it. Election reform, gerrymandering, campaign finance reform, even the constitutional convention process itself, can all be changed by the convention!
I’m afraid that a convention could remove some of the good stuff that is in the constitution already. I’m hopeful that a convention could leave those things alone and do other good things. My amount of fear and hope varies wildly.
The main reason that I’m still feeling ever so slightly towards yes, is this. Right now we have a scenario we can see where labor is putting up an incredibly strong push to get a no vote, and they are probably going to succeed. Well, let’s say the convention happens. Labor’s worst fear comes to pass, and the convention puts forth amendments to the public that will ruin labor rights in the state. If those labor groups can muster enough political will to get a no for the convention as a whole, they can also muster enough political will to get pro-labor delegates at the convention. Therefore, they can also muster enough political will to oppose any anti-labor amendments that come out of a convention. They could even potentially benefit their causes and tilt the current constitution even more in their favor.
The same goes for the environmental groups and others. If they have the political power to get a no vote, then vote yes now. Save the no votes for 2018 and 2019 to make sure your worst fear doesn’t happen, while allowing other good things to possibly get through.
The core of the matter is that with a NO vote, nothing happens, and the status quo is guaranteed to be maintained. That is good, and also bad.
A YES vote, ANYTHING can happen. Which is exciting and also terrifying. Without knowing what the anything is, people seem to be deciding based on what they imagine the “anything” is going to be. I can’t stop imagining all the different anythings, good and bad, making a decision incredibly difficult.