What's with all these awful Youtubers being popular?

I have to write something just to get this stuff out of my head.

When I got back into wrestling in 2016, one of the channels I found compelling was WhatCulture and particularly Adam Blampied’s content. When he was exposed for soliciting nudes from fans in 2017 I was rather shocked. However, in the subsequent years he also behaved in a way I would have hoped for someone with such allegations. He admitted to it very publicly, he conceded how wrong it was, and he went away. I also talked about this in this forum here.

When he returned as part of WrestleTalk I was hesitant at first but due to the way he handled things with his misdeed I was willing to give him a second chance. The content he provided was entertaining and when they launched a sister channel called No Rolls Barred about one of my other big interests in board games I was rather delighted. They also introduced me to Blood on the Clocktower which has become one of my favorites.

When Adam rather abruptly left WT/NRB a year ago I was rather distraught. While I recognized that the statements that lead to it were rather vague, the fact is that it played into similar patterns as before as Adam admits in the video.

I try to reevaluate these things on my own and question my own assumptions. Was I, and the wider community in general, willing to forgive Adam for his past digressions because he is charismatic and entertaining, and with that allowing him to repeat such harmful behavior. Or is that a two-way street because his accuser is also an internet personality that is charismatic and attractive, and therefore we are allowing someone who made amends be ostracized again despite the accusations being very vague and unsubstantiated.

This was in September of last year and there was basically nothing in between except a couple of drama YouTubers making videos recounting the event. Well, until now.

In the last couple of days Adam Blampied released a video with a statement where he admits that he did a similar problematic behavior as in his first around (telling a romantic interest that he was in an open relationship when he wasn’t) but says that this was not followed up on until he had ended his ongoing relationship as well as the romantic relationship he was trying to solicit, and the actual cause of his departure was a professional dispute between two people who appeared as guests on NRB and had some sort of beef, with Adam having previously romantically involved with one of them who then made the accusations when he didn’t fully take her side. This was followed by a video from Angela of HobbyNight, the other side of the dispute who corroborated Adam’s statement.

I believe we have a clearer view of the situation now, but also one that marks out a clear villain. I am just still not sure if that such an easy narrative is the truth, for the same reasons as above.

The details of dramas like this can be scandalously entertaining, even for outsiders with no skin in the game, but as far as whether to drop people who have made mistakes, I’ve come around to a pretty simple policy.

Do people deserve second chances? Yes. We need to stop demanding perfection from people, it’s just not possible. We can’t hold other people to a higher standard than we hold ourselves.

However, we should only give someone a second chance after we have given everyone else a first chance.

Are you hiring a coach for a sports team? Why are you hiring someone who got fired scandalously when there are plenty of people who are qualified for the job who could start their career instead?

Are you looking for a date? Why are you going with the person you know cheated on your friend when you could find someone new and exciting?

Are you looking for a YouTube channel to watch? Why are you watching the person who got banned for being shitty and then came back when there are tons of others in the same space you haven’t even given a chance yet?

Only after going through all the people who are looking for their first chance will I come back and reconsider the people on their second chance. The other benefit of this method is it puts a lot more time between people’s chances. By the time you come to check on them it’s much more likely they’ll have either demonstrated a true change of heart, or screwed up again and shown they still suck.

2 Likes

futurama-shocked

1 Like

Twitch streamer and sentient pile of garbage Asmongold has been banned from twitch for explicitly calling for the genocide of Palestinians. Good riddance.

Edit: Unfortunately it seems he hes only been suspended for 14 days.

For once it’s a name I’ve heard of! I don’t know what games they stream, what they look like, or anything else. But I did know that there was a Twitch streamer named Asmongold.

It’s more than he and his roach-covered bedroom deserve.

In the past week some drama went down in the VTuber world. A popular model creator named Nanoless revealed a bunch of DMs where a VTuber named Sinder and her manager/boyfriend were manipulating her into dropping projects for other clients so that Sinder would have exclusive access to her. This included dropping a project that had been months in the working for another VTuber named Bao The Whale, who considered Sinder a close personal friend. Sinder released some sort of apology, blaming it all on her manager whom she says she has fired, but this has been pretty universally rejected as insincere, especially in the face of other actions by Sinder such as deliberately scheduling collabs and events to collide with plans by other VTubers.

Pretty much the only streamer I follow is Bricky, a “fleshtuber” who has a pretty big following doing video game reviews and he is pretty big into Warhammer. Through him I actually got to experience some VTuber content as he had quite a few collabs with VTubers because in the past year and a half or so a strange Warhammer-to-VTuber pipeline has opened up. I don’t think he’s ever collabed with Sinder directly, but I actually watched some of Sinder’s content as I fell into a minor VTuber hole watching content by people Bricky worked with and then content from people they had on their streams.

I found Sinder quite fun to watch, and this whole thing is very disappointing.

I suspect he’s actually a big reason that pipeline exists at all - Thanks to Adeptus Rediculous, the Warhammer podcast/YT series that he does with Dkdiamantes(an Ex-warframe content creator) and silent producer/editor/peanut gallery Shy(Aka Quietshy, Quite shallow, and like four other handles over time, an Ex-warframe content creator, current artist, and Game Director at LunaticMoon Studios) known for her comedically misanthropic attitude towards her fans and her use of Text-to-speech voices due to being mute).

IIRC, a Vtuber friend of his had him in for a collab or two due to the show, it did numbers, which got others curious and/or introduced some of them to warhammer in a fairly approachable way, and next thing you know, pipeline is pipelinin’

Oh definitely, particular with “react content” to his Every Faction Explained videos. However, I think 40k is in a big rise of popularity in the last couple of years anyway in part due to the lockdowns during the pandemic and people needing hobbies they can do at home, but more recently due to the popularity of games like Helldivers II and Space Marine II.

I think the pipeline goes more like: VTuber encounters a piece of media → Chat says that this is very similar to the setting in 40k or directly related → VTuber becomes interested and wants to find out more → Reacts to Bricky’s content, often contacting Bricky to ask if they can do so.

Probably the Ur-example of this is Matara Kan, Bricky’s most frequent collaborator. Matara debuted as her current persona in October 2023 and since her design is a giant intergalactic space cockroach, she was immediately compared to Tyranids.

Adeptus Ridiculous is also a show I’ve been listening to for years now, mostly while painting my own minis. I find it funny though that a bit before Bricky started to Collab with VTubers through the rest of his internet presence, both Shy and DK started doing VTubing themselves.

Excuse me, a what?

A WHHHHAAATTT??

a “fleshtuber” ?!?!?!?!?!

What an unholy thought !!!

(picture this as that one scene from My Cousin Vinny)

When Bricky is in a colab with three or more VTubers, he thinks of himself as equivalent to this image:

He came up with the term “Fleshtuber” in contrast to “VTuber”, but that is entirely a joke of course.

I actually like the term fleshtuber.

I get the contrast, but man, there’s gotta be a better phrase for that!

Meatuber is probably not much better.

HumeTuber?

I’ve got the scene from Babylon 5 where Delenn is trying out the word Butt.

Someone explains how to vTube on hard more (linux)